Pete Alonso was named to the 2026 All-MLB First Team on Wednesday, November 11, making him the first Baltimore Oriole to earn that distinction since Corbin Burnes claimed it in 2024. The award caps Alonso's first season in an Orioles uniform with one of the most prestigious end-of-year honors in the sport, voted on to recognize the best player at each position across all of Major League Baseball. It is the fourth time in franchise history a Baltimore player has landed on the All-MLB First Team — and the clearest signal yet that Alonso's move to the Chesapeake delivered exactly what the organization needed at first base.

Pete Alonso's 2025 Season Numbers Established the Baseline

To understand what Alonso brought to Baltimore, start with what he showed the year before he arrived. In 2025, Alonso slashed .272/.347/.524 with an OPS of .871 across 162 games. He clubbed 38 home runs, drove in 126 runs, hit 41 doubles, and accumulated 327 total bases. He walked 61 times, took 15 hit-by-pitches, and posted a .305 BABIP — numbers that reflect genuine production, not luck running hot. On the defensive side, he played 1,403 innings at first base, committed 10 errors, and posted a .992 fielding percentage with 100 double plays turned. Those are the credentials Alonso carried into 2026, and the All-MLB First Team selection confirms he held or built on that standard through the full 2026 campaign.

What All-MLB First Team Means and Why It Matters for Baltimore

The All-MLB Team is selected after the season concludes and represents a comprehensive accounting of performance across the entire year — not a single series, not a single month. Earning a First Team nod means the voting pool judged Alonso the best first baseman in baseball for 2026. That is a significant distinction in a position group that consistently features some of the game's most dangerous offensive players.

For the Orioles as a franchise, the honor carries added weight because of how recently the previous one arrived. Corbin Burnes won the award for Baltimore in 2024, meaning the organization now has back-to-back two-year windows in which a player in black and orange was considered among the elite at his position league-wide. Prior to Burnes, the franchise had accumulated three All-MLB First Team selections in total. Alonso's 2026 recognition brings that franchise count to four.

The Franchise Timeline at a Glance

  • All-MLB First Team selections in franchise history: 4
  • Most recent prior winner: Corbin Burnes, 2024
  • Gap between Burnes and Alonso: 2 years
  • Alonso's award date: November 11, 2026

Alonso's Profile as an Oriole

Alonso is 30 years old and his rookie eligibility expired back in 2019, so there is nothing developmental about what he brings to a roster. He is a known quantity — a power-first, run-producing first baseman who has demonstrated durability by playing in 162 games in 2025 and reliability at the position across a long career. His 16.42 at-bats per home run ratio in 2025 placed him among the most consistent power threats in the league, and his 126 RBI illustrated his ability to produce with runners on base.

His .992 fielding percentage and 100 double plays at first base in 2025 also reinforce that the production is not coming at a defensive cost. Alonso gives the Orioles a full package at the position.

What This Honor Signals Heading Into the Offseason

Baltimore is now in the offseason following the 2026 season. The All-MLB First Team announcement is one of the last major pieces of business before the calendar fully turns toward 2027 roster planning. For Alonso, the recognition adds hardware to what by any measure was a successful first full season in Baltimore. For the organization, it reinforces that the first base position is in capable hands.

The Orioles have now produced an All-MLB First Team honoree in two of the last three award cycles. That is not a coincidence — it reflects that Baltimore has been able to attract and keep players performing at the top of the league. Whether the front office can build around that foundation during the offseason roster moves ahead will be the next chapter of the story. For now, Pete Alonso's name sits alongside the best first basemen in baseball in 2026, and that belongs in the record books.